Research Article |
Corresponding author: Neng Fisheri Kurniati ( nfkurniati@fa.itb.ac.id ) Academic editor: Georgi Momekov
© 2023 Neng Fisheri Kurniati, Almira Fathadina.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kurniati NF, Fathadina A (2023) Combination of Empagliflozin and Liraglutide protects heart against isoproterenol-induced myocardial infarction in rats. Pharmacia 70(1): 171-180. https://doi.org/10.3897/pharmacia.70.e96975
|
Cardiovascular benefit of new anti-hyperglycemic agent such as glucagon like peptide-1 receptor agonist (GLP-1RA) or sodium glucose co-transporter-2 inhibitor (SGLT2i) has been proven, with the proposed-mechanism that might be complementary. We investigated the effects of its combination on blood glucose profile and cardiac biomarkers. The rats were given lipid emulsion for 2 weeks, followed by a single dose of streptozotocin (STZ) 35 mg/kg BW, then treated with empagliflozin and/ liraglutide for 30 days while receiving isoproterenol (ISO) 85 mg/kg on day 29 and 30. The results showed no superior improvement on fasting blood glucose (FBG) and insulin sensitivity (KITT) in the combination group compared to empagliflozin/liraglutide group. However, the combination group showed a higher inhibition in almost all biomarkers, specifically against the elevation of CK-MB compared to one of these agents alone. The histopathological examination using H&E staining even showed a minimal inflammation and gap between cardiomyocytes. These findings may indicate the combination of empagliflozin and liraglutide has a better cardiac protection effect.
diabetic cardiomyopathy, GLP1-RA, isoproterenol, myocardial infarction, SGLT2i, type 2 DM
Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a metabolic disease characterized by hyperglycemia resulting from defects of insulin secretion, function, or both (
According to guidelines by American Diabetes Association (ADA), patients with T2DM and established or in high risk of ASCVD are recommended to use one of SGLT2is or GLP-1RAs that have been demonstrated to have cardiovascular benefit, independent of HbA1c and metformin use (
Although the cardiovascular and kidney benefits of both classes are well-established, the molecular mechanism of this benefits are still being elucidated, and whether the combination will provide added risk reduction remains questioned. ADA guidelines only recommend the combination of both classes if the HbA1c above target, although the addition of one of this class after another for patient with or in high risk of ASCVD may be considered because of its proposed mechanism that may provide complementary outcomes (
Not only on cardiovascular risk factor, some studies may also suggest a direct positive effect of the combination on cardiovascular. One study suggested the benefit of dual therapy on vascular and cardiac function in T2DM patient with high CVD risk as an add-on therapy to metformin which was superior compared to SGLT2i or GLP1-RA alone (
Therefore, in this study we investigated the cardioprotective effect of both agents against several cardiac biomarkers that usually elevated in damaged heart, to suggest whether the combination is able to protect the heart better than SGLT2i and GLP1-RA alone, not only in diabetic rats but also diabetic rats with MI. We also investigated the effect of its combination on blood glucose profile to confirm whether it shows any significant effect in lowering blood glucose level and improving insulin sensitivity. We used agents that has been approved for reduction of cardiovascular event such as liraglutide and empagliflozin. Empagliflozin now is the only SGLT2i that has been approved by FDA for both CVD benefit and heart failure indication (
Thirty male Wistar rats, aged 10–12 weeks, weighing 200–250 g, were purchased from ITB School of Life Sciences and Technology and housed in the animal laboratory at ITB School of Pharmacy in separate cages under controlled environmental condition (12 h light/dark cycle and temperature 24–26 °C) with free access of standard chow and water. The research protocols were approved by the ethics committee for animal research of Bandung Institute of Technology (No.01/KEPHP-ITB/2-2022, 18 February 2022).
The rats were acclimated for 7 days before the study, then randomly divided into 6 groups as follows:
T2DM are characterized by the reduction of insulin sensitivity with impaired insulin secretion. Therefore, this study used the combination model to mimic those pathology (
ISO was obtained from Tokyo-Chemical Industry (Shanghai, China). ISO at dose of 85 mg/kg BW was given twice (i.p.) on day 29 and 30, at 24 hours interval, to induce myocardial infarction. ISO was dissolved in NaCl 0.9% and prepared fresh on the day of induction. The AMI state was confirmed by the elevation of cardiac biomarkers (
The blood glucose control profile was obtained from FBG measurement at the same hour and time-points throughout the study to eliminate the variation of fasting duration of each test. Blood glucose concentration from tail vein was measured using Easy TouchÒ blood glucosemeter. IPITT was performed using insulin (NovorapidÒ) at dose of 0.5 U/kg BW via i.p. (
The blood samples were collected from tail (before MI induction) and from heart (after MI induction, as a terminal procedure), then serum samples were separated for the estimation of cardiac biomarkers. The serum levels of CK, CK-MB, LDH, AST and ALT were measured using commercially kits according to the manufacturer’s instructions (DiaSys Diagnostic Systems GmbH, Holzheim, Germany for CK, CK-MB, LDH, and ALT; Glory Diagnostic, Spain for AST). All the biomarkers were assessed using Microlab 300, ELITech Group, France.
The rat’s heart was dissected, washed with 0.9% cold saline, then fixed in 10% neutral buffered formalin. The left ventricle then embedded in paraffin and sectioned at 3 µm thickness using microtome. The tissue specimens were stained using hematoxylin and eosin (H&E). Characteristic of myocytes abnormality such as coagulative necrosis with absent nuclei, hyper eosinophilia of cytoplasm, and an interstitial neutrophil infiltration were observed using light microscope (Olympus BX51) at 400× magnifications (
The data obtained in this study were processed using Minitab version 20 and analyzed using one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test. Considered significantly different at p<0.05.
The animal study protocol was approved by the ethics committee for animal research of Bandung Institute of Technology (No.01/KEPHP-ITB/2-2022, 18 February 2022).
Insulin sensitivity profile
Insulin sensitivity was determined at baseline (before the induction), after the induction, and after receiving one or both agents for 4 weeks. The KITT values are shown in Table
KITT profile at baseline, after induction, and after treated with SGLT2i and/GLP-1RA.
Groups | KITT (%/minute) | ||
---|---|---|---|
Baseline | After induction | After treated | |
Normal control | 1.01±0.13 | 1.09±0.21 | 0.98±0.08 |
DM | 1.14±0.10 | 0.69±0.08a,c | 0.61±0.14a,c |
Liraglutide | 0.94±0.04 | 0.69±0.17a,c | 0.85±0.06c |
Empagliflozin | 1.00±0.16 | 0.57±0.15a,c | 0.93±0.14b,d |
Combination | 1.05±0.27 | 0.67±0.16a,c | 0.97±0.10b |
Before the induction, there were no significant difference of KITT value between groups that indicates similar insulin sensitivity at baseline. After given lipid emulsion for 14 days, all the tested groups showed significantly lower KITT value compared to normal control and baseline, indicate the reduction of blood glucose disappearance rate from blood (%/min) after given insulin (reduction of insulin sensitivity). The group treated with empagliflozin and/or liraglutide for 4 weeks showed the increase of KITT value. The KITT value of all treated group were not significantly different to normal control group. However, only empagliflozin and combination group that significantly higher than DM group, even not significantly different from baseline. Even though these findings may indicate lesser improvement in liraglutide group compared to other two groups, all three treated groups (empagliflozin and/liraglutide alone) were not statistically different (p>0.05), showing relatively similar KITT value.
Blood glucose control was obtained from FBG measurement at several time-points (before induction, after induction, and every week while treated with one or both agents). The FBG level at each time point are shown in Table
FBG profile at baseline, after induction, and after treated with SGLT2i and/GLP1-RA.
Group | Fasting blood glucose (mg/dL) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baseline | After induction | After treated (Week-) | ||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |||
Normal control | 93.80±7.53 | 101.00±12.53 | 91.60±12.10 | 91.20±13.88 | 98.00±12.19 | 89.00±8.28 |
DM | 93.25±3.50 | 259.00±109.77a,c | 269.00±93.68a,c | 312.50±135.93a,c | 350.25±121.93a,c | 407.25±89.11a,c |
Liraglutide | 93.00±6.98 | 266.00±85.81a,c | 115.25±16.58b,d | 123.00±24.18b,d | 122.00±12.94b,c,d | 106.50±9.18b,d |
Empagliflozin | 97.25±8.77 | 267.25±75.59a,c | 112.00±18.67b,d | 127.75±19.31b,c,d | 130.50±8.43b,c,d | 106.5±11.27b,d |
Combination | 94.20±13.52 | 253.40±26.84a,c | 96.00±5.66b,d | 108.60±22.32b,d | 126.60±22.03b,d | 95.20±7.09b,d |
Cardiac biomarkers were obtained from serum collected before and after ISO induction to assess the biomarker changes at DM only state and at DM with AMI state. The biomarkers level i.e., CK, CK-MB, LDH, AST, and ALT before AMI are shown in Table
Effect of empagliflozin and/liraglutide on cardiac biomarkers in diabetic rats.
Groups | Cardiac biomarkers (U/L) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | CK-MB | LDH | AST | ALT | |
Normal Control | 123.81±16.16b | 121.19±10.56b | 307.93±63.04b | 99.32±20.97b | 52.80±20.32 |
DM | 361.64±84.44a | 244.53±24.60a | 914.53±196.28a | 168.98±51.12a | 101.56±46.82 |
Liraglutide | 192.48±44.06b | 184.75±24.01a | 428.22±44.84b | 148.40±10.34 | 55.01±18.34 |
Empagliflozin | 149.19±70.24b | 147.00±18.68b | 508.97±129.63b | 142.40±36.57 | 70.93±7.67 |
Combination | 103.59±30.74b | 99.07±18.38b,c | 325.10±103.73b | 125.32±11.86 | 53.29±10.76 |
The CK, CK-MB, LDH, and AST levels were significantly elevated in DM group. The elevation of CK and LDH biomarker were not significantly different between liraglutide, empagliflozin, and combination group, and even compared to normal control group, indicate similar inhibition of all three treated group for both parameters. For CK-MB parameter, only empagliflozin and combination group that were not significantly different compared to normal control. However, empagliflozin group was not significantly different from liraglutide group, which may indicate higher inhibition on the elevation of CK-MB level in combination group compared to either these agents alone. As for AST and ALT, these parameters were not significantly elevated in all treated group. The biomarkers level of all treated group then compared to DM group and transformed into percentage of inhibition, shown in Table
Percentage inhibition of serum cardiac biomarkers elevation in treated vs DM group.
Groups | Inhibition of cardiac biomarker serum elevation (%) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | CK-MB | LDH | AST | ALT | |
Liraglutide | 46.77 | 23.48 | 53.18 | 12.18 | 45.83 |
Empagliflozin | 58.74 | 39.11 | 44.37 | 15.73 | 30.16 |
Combination | 71.36 | 58.97 | 64.45 | 25.83 | 47.53 |
The biomarkers level after ISO induction are shown in Table
Effect of empagliflozin and/liraglutide on cardiac biomarkers in diabetic rats induced with AMI.
Groups | Cardiac biomarkers (U/L) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | CK-MB | LDH | AST | ALT | |
Normal control | 136.85±28.27b | 134.61±12.87b | 325.37±90.41b | 115.79±17.25b | 51.86±16.89b |
DM | 361.13±103.63a,b | 263.51±33.41a,b | 1012.08±191.39a,b | 189.15±50.86a | 96.63±41.72 |
DM+ISO | 596.76±28.18a,c | 438.29±50,79a,c | 1679.11±255.76a,c | 247.89±56.45a | 123.98±59.32a |
Liraglutide | 338.93±26.61a,b | 238.39±26.33a,b | 763.63±83.46a,b | 179.15±21.89 | 64.48±16.28 |
Empagliflozin | 275.17±145.08b | 214.28±18.81a,b | 671.68±102.99a,b | 180.40±12.19 | 69.54±19.12 |
Combination | 175.99±35.94b,* | 125.06±19.32b,# | 452.60±151.38b | 145.72±20.84b | 64.60±7.43 |
As for CK-MB and LDH parameter, the levels in all three treated group were significantly lower than DM+ISO group. However, only combination group that was not significantly different from normal control. The CK-MB level in combination group even significantly lower than both empagliflozin and liraglutide group. As for AST parameter, all three treated group were not significantly different from normal control, however only combination group that was significantly lower than DM+ISO group.
All these findings may indicate better inhibition on the elevation of these biomarkers in combination group. The data then transformed into percentage of inhibition, shown in Table
Percentage inhibition of serum cardiac biomarkers elevation in treated vs DM+ISO group.
Groups | Inhibition of cardiac biomarker serum elevation (%) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CK | CK-MB | LDH | AST | ALT | |
Liraglutide | 43.21 | 45.61 | 54.52 | 27.73 | 47.99 |
Empagliflozin | 53.89 | 51.11 | 59.99 | 27.23 | 43.91 |
Combination | 70.51 | 71.48 | 73.05 | 41.22 | 47.90 |
In histopathological examination using H&E staining, regular arrangement of myocardial fibers was shown in normal control group (Fig.
Histopathological examination of heart tissue stained with H&E staining and 400× magnification. a Control group; b DM group; c DM+ISO group; d Liraglutide group; e Empagliflozin group, and f Combination group. The irregular arrangement of myocardial fibers and wide gap between cardiomyocytes (showed in black arrow) may indicate massive cardiomyocytes death. While massive infiltration of inflammatory cells with the absent of nuclei (showed in white arrow) may indicate coagulative necrosis.
Several in vivo studies have been conducted to confirmed cardiovascular benefit of both classes. Liraglutide, dapagliflozin, and empagliflozin showed cardioprotective effect in diabetic cardiomyopathy model (
Streptozotocin (STZ) has been shown to cause pancreatic islet b-cell destruction and widely used to induce diabetes in animal study (
Lipid emulsion given for two weeks was significantly lowering the insulin sensitivity based on KITT value calculated from IPITT. This lipid emulsion contained triglycerides (TGs) that might increase the TG level in blood which has positive correlation with insulin resistance (
After the induction was confirmed and have been treated with either or both classes for 4 weeks, the FBG profile improved significantly even to a normal level that indicates a well-controlled FBG level in all treated group. In this study, one of these agents alone was already sufficient to normalize the FBG level, thus the combination showed no superior effect compared to empagliflozin/liraglutide group. This finding was different to some clinical trials where the additive glucose-lowering benefit were observed. This might be due to different setting and how these agents are combined. In clinical trials, the GLP-1RA was added to patient with inadequately controlled of T2DM, even after receiving SGLT2i therapy (
There are few differences in human and animal heart structure, that is challenging to design a good model to mimic pathophysiology of MI in human. In this study, we used isoproterenol (ISO) as an indirect approach to induce MI in diabetic rats. ISO is sympathomimetic agent that stimulates both b-1 and b-2 receptors, causing ischemia due to imbalance of oxygen demand and supply in heart, that further leads to MI (
Cardiomyocytes death causing the leak of several proteins into the circulation, thus the level of cardiac enzymes tends to be elevated in the serum after MI (
The biomarker measurement before ISO induction showed significant elevation of almost all parameters (except for ALT) compared to normal control group. These findings were similar to previous in vivo study where cardiomyopathy may occur in diabetes model which leads to myocardial necrosis causing the elevation of several cardiac biomarkers in serum (
Glucose-lowering therapies alone were already proven to reduce microvascular event, while it is more challenging to prevent macrovascular complication in T2DM (
Several studies suggested other cardioprotective effects of GLP-1RAs through the attenuation of atherosclerosis, reduced inflammation, and some beneficial action on myocardial function which improved cardiovascular outcomes (
Even though the SGLT2 is not expressed in heart, its direct cardioprotective effect might be due to the modulation of autophagy. Autophagy is a complex process in response of several stimuli and is important to eliminate defect organelle associated with oxidative stress. Insufficient or excessive activation of autophagy may be harmful in MI. SGLT2i inhibited Na+/H+ exchanger 1 (NHE1) on cardiomyocytes that suppress excessive autophagy during ischemia (
This study has several limitations, which only focuses on the effect of both agent against several biomarkers that could leaked to circulation when myocardial damage or death occur. The biomarkers used in this study were relatively non- to almost specific to cardiomyocytes. In the future, the measurement of Troponin-I and the isomers of LDH (to calculated LDH-1/LDH-2 ratio), which more specific to cardiomyocyte, might be used. Several oxidative stress markers also haven’t been measured yet to support the mechanism or pathway related to cardiomyocyte survival for each agent and combination therapy. This study also may be limited to liraglutide and empagliflozin, not other drugs in the same class.
This study suggested better cardioprotective effect of liraglutide and empagliflozin combined in diabetic subjects induced with AMI, based on its inhibition against the elevation of several cardiac biomarkers. These results may be used as a consideration for clinical study to provide definitive evidence regarding the additional reduction of cardiovascular outcomes for the combination therapy. GLP-1RAs and SGLT2is are categorized as an expensive antihyperglycemic agents, thus cost-effectiveness study to support the combination to be used earlier in a newly diagnostic T2DM patient with high risk or established ASCVD is needed.
This research was funded by P2MI ITB.