Review Article |
Corresponding author: Stefka Ivanova ( ivanovastefka_pharm@yahoo.com ) Academic editor: Plamen Peikov
© 2022 Danka Obreshkova, Stefka Ivanova, Pavlina Yordanova-Laleva .
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Obreshkova D, Ivanova S, Yordanova-Laleva P (2022) Influence of chemical structure and mechanism of hydrolysis on pharmacological activity and toxicological profile of approved platinum drugs. Pharmacia 69(3): 645-653. https://doi.org/10.3897/pharmacia.69.e87494
|
The problems with platinum complexes are resistance and toxicity of anticancer therapy. The aim of current study is the comparison of the influence of chemical structure and mechanism of hydrolysis on pharmacological activity and toxicological profile of approved in platinum drugs: Cisplatin, Carboplatin, Oxaliplatin, Nedaplatin, Lobaplatin, Heptaplatin, Satraplatin. Hydrolysis of Carboplatin and Nedaplatin occurs by double step hydration, to obtain the same active products as with Cisplatin: diaqudiamine-platinum. The similarity in mechanisms of hydrolysis of Oxaliplatin, Lobaplatin Heptaplatin, and Satraplatin is that the first part of the hydrolysis corresponds to the ring-opening and addition of the first water molecule, and in the second step of reaction occur the loss of the ligand and the formation of the di-aquated product by the addition of a second water molecule. Cisplatin, Carboplatin, and Oxaliplatin are nephrotoxic. Cisplatin and Heptaplatin are nephrotoxic. The similar dose-limiting effects of Carboplatin, Oxaliplatin, Nedaplatin, Lobaplatin, and Satraplatin is myelosuppression.
Cisplatin, approved derivatives, hydrolysis, pharmacology, toxicology
Carcinogenesis is a multi-stage process of transformation of cells into tumors, which includes initiation, promotion, malignant transformation of cells and progression. The breast carcinomas in women and the lung, prostate and colon carcinomas in men, recently have been increased (
Cisplatin (cis-dichlorodiamineplatinum II) (Fig.
By the USA Food and Drug Administration Cisplatin has been approved for treatment of testicular and ovarian cancers on December 1978. The compound has been marketed first in Canada and in the USA (
The drug causes the DNA damages and formation of the cytotoxic DNA-adducts (
Side effects of compound are: nephrotoxicity, neurotoxicity, transient blindness and seizures (
Currently applied in clinical practice worldwide are: Cisplatin and it’s structural analog of II generation Carboplatin (1993); derivative of III generation Oxaliplatin (2002) in France, Carboplatin analog – II generation: Nedaplatin in Japan; Oxaliplatin derivatives – III generation: Lobaplatin in China and Heptaplatin in the North Korea; oral derivative Satraplatin (Ndagi et al. 2013). To date, no analog of Cisplatin has been developed, that is completely superior to it, in terms of both therapeutic effect and spectrum of action (
In March 1989 Bristol-Myers Squibb has obtained the approval for application of the drug. The compound is the most successful platinum complex of the second generation with clinical administration for the treatment of ovarian, head, neck, lung, breast cancer (
The main drawback of Carboplatin is the hematotoxicity (
The compound is applied for treatment of non-small cell lung cancer, head, neck, ovarian, and breast cancer (Ndagi et al. 2013). Oxaliplatin with Folic acid and 5-Fluorouracil is effective in the therapy of colorectal cancer (
The major reason for the discontinuation of treatment with Oxaliplatin are neurotoxicity (
Indications in Japan for Nedaplatin are for the treatment of head, neck, esophagus, non-small cell lung, cervical, testicular, and prostate cancer (
Compared with Cisplatin, Nedaplatin has lower nephro-, neuro- oto- and gastrointestinal toxicity, and leukopenia. Dose-limiting toxicity is myelosuppression: thrombocytopenia, neutropenia, and anemia (
Heptaplatin was approved by the Korean Food and Drug Administration in 1999 for the treatment of gastric cancer (
Lobaplatin has been introduced in China for the treatment of chronic myelocytic leukemia, hypopharyngeal carcinoma, esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (
The side effects of the drug are thrombocytopenia, leucopenia, neutropenia, and granulocytopenia (
Satraplatin is administered against lung, prostate, and ovarian cancer (
Cisplatin is a complex of platinum (II), coordinated to two chloride and two ammonia groups, where chloride ligands are in cis-geometry. The drug is initially activated intracellularly by hydration with water molecules, whereby labile ligands (chloride atoms in cis-geometry) are sequentially replaced, forming more chemically reactive to DNA mono- and diaqua metabolites (Fig.
Due to their pronounced electrophilic properties, aqua compounds covalently bind to nucleophilic nitrogen-containing purine DNA bases to form DNA-adducts: monofunctional in one leaving group or bifunctional in two leaving groups. The presence of two labile ligands appearing as leaving groups in these nucleophilic substitution reactions, determines the possibility of the formation of intrachain and, less frequently, interchain crosslinks in the DNA molecule. Cisplatin preferably binds to the N7 atom of the imidazole ring of the purine base guanine (G) of DNA and with N3 and 4-NH2 of cytosine and N1 and 6-NH2 adenine (A). Pt-DNA binding is most often performed on one strand of DNA and the internal adducts include GpG (65%), ApG (25%) or the adducts include guanines of opposite strands of DNA G-G cross-linking (5%).
Adducts cause disturbances in the structure of DNA: inhibit cellular processes of replication and transcription, cause prolonged G2 phase of cell cycle and lead to programmed cell death (apoptosis). Adducts are also formed between DNA and some proteins. Bifunctional adducts, which form intra-helix or inter-helix “cross-links”, cause basic and local disturbances in the structure of DNA. In intermolecular adducts, such as Cisplatin-DNA proteins, the cross-bonds, responsible for blocking replication, are the main damages, activating apoptosis (
In Carboplatin two chloride atoms are replaced by an oxygen bidendate cyclobutane-dicarboxylate group. Slow hydrolysis of the drug occurs by double hydration to the same products as with Cisplatin: diaqudiamine-platinum. The decomposition in water take place through a biphasic mechanism with a ring-opening process and aquation in frst part, followed by the loss of the malonato ligand nad second aquation (Fig.
Carboplatin binds to DNA more slowly due to the stability of carboxylate ligand and slower hydrolysis. Aqua-complex species react with DNA, proteins or other macromolecules.
Hydrolysis of Oxaliplatin corresponds to the ring-opening, the addition of water molecules, and the loss of the monodentate oxalato ligand. The rate-limiting process for the neutral hydrolysis is the ring-opening reaction (Fig.
Nedaplatin has ten times greater solubility in water than Cisplatin, and is hydrolysed by double hydration to the same active metabolite as with Cisplatin: diaqudiamine-platinum. The hydrolysis reaction processes is illustrated on Fig.
The first step of the mechanism corresponds to the ring opening and first quatiion, followed by the second part, which is characterized by the loss of ligand and second hydratation. In acid conditions, the second hydrolysis reaction is the rate limiting, and in neutral conditions the rate limiting step is found to be the first hydrolysis process (
Nedaplatin binds to guanine in the DNA. In attempts of mismatch repair protein complex for repairing of the DNA by removing of the platinum cross-links, this complex forms single strand breaks and induces apoptosis after the repair attempt has failed. In combination with radiation treatment, the radiosensitizing effect of Nedaplatin is due to the formation of lethal double strand breaks (Schimada et al 2013).
The bio-transformation of Heptaplatin (Fig.
In the hydrolysis mechanism of Lobaplatin in aqueous medium under neutral conditions, the ring opening reaction is found to be the rate limiting. The completely hydrolysed complex reacts with the DNA purine bases. The ligand detachment is described as the rate limiting step in acidic conditions and monohydrated complex reacts with DNA.The hydrolysis of Lobaplatin is presented on Fig.
Pt IV-complexes are in an “inactive” form and react mainly with proteins in the bloodstream, and in the cells they accumulate through passive diffusion. Activation of Pt IV complexes is accomplished by reduction to Pt II, with electron transfer occurring in parallel with the release of axial ligands. Reduction of Pt IV to Pt II is a necessary condition for achieving antitumor activity, as six-coordinate octahedral Pt IV compounds are able to minimize unwanted side reactions with biomolecules and are more kinetically inert and less reactive and more resistant to ligand substitution than four-coordinate Pt II. Depending on the nature of the ligands, that determine the specific thermodynamic and kinetic properties, some Pt IV complexes can bind to DNA, causing DNA deformation. Studies on the cytotoxic properties of Pt IV complexes show that, like Pt II compounds, they are localized in the cell nucleus and the Pt IV-DNA adducts formed are analogous to those formed by Cisplatin. In vitro studies indicate that Pt IV complexes are characterized by higher efficacy, than the respective Pt II complexes. Pt IV complexes bypass inconvenient intravenous administration, due to kinetic inertness, like Satraplatin – the first platinum oral antineoplastic agent. Satraplatin has increased bioavailability due to the two polar acetate groups, which hydrolysis is presented on Fig.
The major way of the development of the resistance to Cisplatin and it’s derivatives is through a mammalian nucleotide excision repair pathway, which repairs damaged DNA. In comparison to other platinum anti-cancer drugs, due to the different adducts on the molecule (cyclohexamine), Satraplatin is not recognized by the DNA repair proteins, the DNA remains damaged, and DNA can not be replicated, resistance is solved. By binding to guanine residues Satraplatin inhibits DNA replication and transcription which leads to apoptosis (
The classic structural requirements for the manifestation of antitumor activity, derived on the basis of the structure of Cisplatin are:
Prospects for the creation of new platinum complexes are various ligands – amines and alkylamines, purines and pyrimidines, hydantoins, carbonyl radicals, which produce compounds with selective cytotoxicity or inhibitory effect on resistant tumors. Modifications of leaving groups (labile, hydrolyzable or exchangeable ligands) in the main classes of platinum complexes affect the cytotoxic activity, spectrum of action and the toxicological profile of platinum analogs.
The leaving group is important for the spectrum of platinum cytostatics and in the order: Cl-, oxalato-, cyclobutanedicarboxylato-, reduces cross-resistance in Cisplatin-resistant tumors. In the molecule of Carboplatin, platinum is bound to cyclobutanedicarboxylic acid. In complexes, based on hydroxycarboxylic acids (lactic, glycolic), platinum is bidently linked to the oxygen atom of the carboxyl and hydroxyl functional groups. The leaving groups are: cyclobutanedicarboxylic acid in Carboplatin, anion of glycolic acid in Nedaplatin, bidentate-bound lactate in Lobaplatin, bidentate oxalate anion in Oxaliplatin. The conversion of carboxylate analogs to active diaquacomplexes: 1) occurs mainly intracellularly, and with the higher stability, than chloride ions, causes of cytotoxicity at higher concentrations, than Cisplatin, and 2) leads in lower nephrotoxic potential, due to reduced direct interaction of cytotoxic metabolites with nucleophilic thiol groups in the kidney. Carboplatin and Nedaplatin are precursors of Cisplatin because their metabolism produces is intermediate derivative dichloro-diamine platinum. The DNA-adducts, formed by Carboplatin are the same, as those, formed by Cisplatin, but 20–40 times higher concentrations of Carboplatin are required and the rate of adducts formation is 10 times slower (
The tightly bound carrier ligands (the ammonia molecules in Cisplatin, Carboplatin, Nedaplatin) do not interact with aqueous molecules or nucleophilic nitrogen-containing DNA bases, and their modifications lead to significant changes in the antitumor activity, spectrum of action and profile of toxicological effects. The ammonia groups in Cisplatin are partially or completely replaced by mono- or bidentate nitrogen-containing ligands: aliphatic, alicyclic and aromatic mono- and diamines or heterocyclic compounds: 1,2-diaminocyclohexane (DACH) ligand in Oxaliplatin; seven-membered Pt-1,2-bis-(methylamino) cyclobutane chelated ring (Lobaplatin). An increase in the number of atoms in the heterocycle (4 to 6) contributes to greater efficacy in Cisplatin-resistant tumors. Important characteristic of DACH complexes is activity in Cisplatin-resistant tumors, but a limiting factor is neurotoxicity, associated with DACH-ligand. Oxaliplatin causes higher cytotoxicity than Cisplatin, inhibiting nucleic acid polymerases, and initiating apoptosis. Higher cytotoxicity of Oxaliplatin is due to hydrophobic properties, increasing the accumulation by actively transporting membrane proteins, overexpressed in tumor cells. The problems with chemotherapy are resistance and toxicity. Antitumor drugs have no selectivity for tumor cells, but also can kill normal cells with high proliferative activity: cells of the bone marrow hematopoiesis, and in gastrointestinal tract. Myelosuppression leads to a risk of infection and is characteristic primarily of alkylating cytostatics and antimetabolites. Toxicity can be decreased by combination therapy, polynuclear platinum agents, Pt IV prodrugs, targeted nanocarriers: (polymers, liposomes) (
The dose-limiting effects of approved for chemotherapy platinum complexes are:
The problems with anticancer therapy is toxicity. Cisplatin, Carboplatin, and Oxaliplatin are nephrotoxic. Cisplatin and Heptaplatin are nephrotoxic. The similar dose-limiting effects of Carboplatin, Oxaliplatin, Nedaplatin Lobaplatin Satraplatin is myelosuppression: (