Review Article |
Corresponding author: Wamidh H. Talib ( altaei_wamidh@yahoo.com ) Academic editor: Georgi Momekov
© 2024 Wamidh H. Talib, Aseel J. Ali, Media Mohammed Baban, Jehan Abdul Sattar Salman, Hadeel Shaher Al Junaidi, Layan Abdulrahem Jumah, Rana Hameed Radhi, Ruba Emad Fleifel, Sara Feras Abuarab, Arkan Hadi Al-Yasari, Rawan W. Hadi, Anfal Al-Dalaeen.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Talib WH, Ali AJ, Baban MM, Salman JAS, Al Junaidi HS, Jumah LA, Radhi RH, Fleifel RE, Abuarab SF, Al-Yasari AH, Hadi RW, Al-Dalaeen A (2024) From weight loss to cancer treatment: Fasting as an adjuvant anticancer therapy. Pharmacia 71: 1-13. https://doi.org/10.3897/pharmacia.71.e122170
|
The number of studies that have been conducted on the possible benefits of different types of fasting or calorie restriction on cancer therapy, including the likelihood that these treatments lessen side effects, has been limited. However, the results are nevertheless promising.
Chemotherapy’s adverse effects have led to a quest for options that reduce reliance on it. The susceptibility of tumorous cells to specific metabolites and nutrient deficiency is increasingly recognized as a key characteristic of the disease.
This review delves into the data on various fasting methods and calorie restriction in rodents and humans, with a focus on biological adaptations that could potentially lower cancer risk or enhance cancer treatment results. We also emphasize recent scientific developments regarding the use of prolonged fasting and fasting-mimicking diets as a possible additional treatment for patients receiving immunotherapy or other treatments. This approach shows promise in enhancing treatment effectiveness, preventing resistance, and minimizing side effects.
This study proposes that combining fasting and calorie restriction with chemotherapy, immunotherapy, or other therapies might be a potential technique to improve treatment efficacy, avoid resistance, and reduce adverse effects.
cancer metabolism, glucose, Warburg effect
The risk of having cancer is significantly influenced by dietary and lifestyle variables, with some malignancies being more reliant on dietary patterns than others (
The levels of glucose, insulin, glucagon, growth hormone (GH), insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1), glucocorticoids, and adrenaline that are circulating in the body contribute to the coordination of the fasting response. Insulin levels begin to decrease during the early post-absorptive phase, which typically lasts between six and twenty-four hours. At the same time, glucagon levels begin to increase, which stimulates the breakdown of liver glycogen stores (which are exhausted after around twenty-four hours) and the consequent release of glucose for energy (
Fasting protects healthy cells from damage, an effect that has persisted through evolution and which has been shown to increase life expectancy and health span in experimental animals (
This study examined how fasting affects the development and management of cancer. The studies reviewed provide researchers with a thorough understanding of the molecular foundations of fasting’s impact on cancer.
Cancer is a disorder characterized by the uncontrolled growth of certain cells in the body with the ability to metastasize to other parts of the body. Anywhere in the body can be the starting point for this illness, and either malignant or benign (non-cancerous) cells might proliferate there. Unlike malignant tumors, benign tumors do not penetrate or spread to surrounding tissues (
Research on the impact of fasting on cancer cells has increased due to cancer cells being sensitive to nutritional restriction and relying on certain metabolites and hormones. It is important to consider whether fasting in any of its forms might prevent or postpone the development of cancer.
Studies on chronic caloric restriction without malnutrition and short-term fasting (STF) for less than 24 hours revealed that these treatments play significant therapeutic roles in preventing the toxicity of chemotherapy and radiotherapy on normal tissues and halting tumor growth and metastasis in non-human primates. (
As a result, research on long-term calorie-restricted human participants has unexpectedly demonstrated a decrease in hormonal and metabolic markers linked to cancer risk. Because chronic calorie restriction causes unacceptable weight loss and takes a long time to demonstrate results, it is not a clinically viable intervention. Extensive preclinical studies have shown that short fasting enhances the efficacy of chemotherapeutic medications in the treatment of many types of malignancies, such as pancreatic, breast, and melanoma. However, because STF strengthens the stress resistance of healthy cells, it has demonstrated its capacity to protest against the damaging effects of chemotherapy. When healthy cells are deprived of nutrients, they spend more energy on maintenance and repair, which makes them more resistant to chemotherapy. Therefore, chemotherapy induces apoptosis and increases DNA damage in tumor cells while sparing healthy cells when used in conjunction with short-term fasting (
In contrast to numerous cancer therapies, brief fasting typically leads to mild and manageable side effects such as weakness, nausea, and headache. Furthermore, fasting is an affordable and convenient approach that demonstrates potential for effectively treating a wide variety of cancers (
Type of diet | Description | Schedule | IGF1 reduction | Glucose reduction | Ketone bodies increase | Protection from chemotherapy toxicity | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fasting or FMD | A calorie-restricted, low-serum, low-glucose, low-carbohydrate diet | 2–5 consecutive days/month | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes (It has the potential to prevent chemotherapy-induced adverse effects and DNA damage in healthy cells). | ( |
Intermittent fasting | Alternate periods of fasting and free feeding/eating. | Chronic | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes (healthy cells are prompted to adopt a sluggish division and a well-protected phase, which shields them from damaging shocks created by anticancer medications). | ( |
Ketogenic diet | Regulated calorie intake | Chronic | Yes | No | Yes | NA | ( |
Calorie restriction | Vitamins and minerals. No other dierty constituent | Chronic | Only in the presence of protein restriction | No | No | Yes | ( |
The oxidation of carbon bonds during glucose metabolism enables the capture of energy in the form of ATP. The foundation for maintaining all mammalian life is this procedure. The oxidative phosphorylation and the citric acid cycle are not the strategies that cancer cells solely use to generate energy; oncologists have noticed that cancer cells make energy in a manner that is distinct from that of healthy cells. Cancer cells generate energy via a process known as anaerobic glycolysis. To maintain their high rates of cellular proliferation, these cells mostly depend on glucose. The Warburg effect makes this apparent. The Warburg effect supports the tumor microenvironment, promoting the tumor cells’ growth. Nevertheless, the Warburg effect offers signaling functions to tumor cells. Thorough investigation into the Warburg effect in cancer cells has increased our understanding of the elements that support tumor cell growth. Exploring nutritional and pharmacological treatments could enhance our understanding of the Warburg effect (Liberti et al. 2016).
Healthy cells may adjust to lack of nutrients during brief fasting periods by transitioning from using glucose to utilizing fatty acids and ketone bodies for energy. However, short-term fasting up-regulates oxidative phosphorylation while down-regulates anaerobic glycolysis; thus, “the anti-Warburg effect” results in apoptosis and oxidative stress of tumor cells (Fig.
Although the necessity of food for humans is crucial, fasting is suggested to enhance the organism’s survival that is capable of enduring harsh or challenging conditions such as food scarcity, extreme temperatures, and UV radiation. Similarly, studies have proposed fasting as a way to decrease the toxic influence of chemotherapy (
Growth factors and hormonal changes influence gene regulation, affecting cell processes such as proliferation, differentiation, and DNA repair, leading to increased food consumption. This promotes cellular growth and survival despite the presence of cancer-causing mutations. Restricting food intake and nutrition significantly affects hormone levels and growth factors, eventually lowering the risk of cancer (
During short-term fasting, serum glucose levels decrease, while glucagon promotes the creation of glucose inside the body. After twenty-four hours, glycogen reserves are exhausted. At this point, the brain is supplied with the required glucose for energy by gluconeogenesis, and fatty acids become the major energy source for the rest of the body. Ketone bodies are then formed by oxidation of fatty acids (
Insulin levels drop significantly after 36–72 hours, leading to a fast reduction in Insulin-like Growth Factor 1 (IGF-1) synthesis. IGF-1 concentrations are strongly correlated with the high probability of developing several forms of cancer. Growth hormone (GH) stimulates the action of IGF-1 from the liver once it is released into the circulation. Due to prolonged fasting, the liver loses its sensitivity towards GH; thus, IGF-1 is reduced. Because of decreased circulating insulin and IGF, negative feedback is diminished, which leads to increased plasma GH levels. (
FMD stands for a diet that restricts calories and is low in glucose and carbohydrates. Cancer cells are increasingly being recognized for their vulnerability to lack of nutrients and reliance on certain metabolites. Fasting or fast-like diets (FMDs) induce notable alterations in growth factor and metabolite levels, hindering cancer cells’ ability to adapt and survive while enhancing the efficacy of cancer therapy. Fasting or FMDs enhance chemotherapy resistance in normal cells without affecting cancer cells. They also speed up tissue regeneration in normal tissues, possibly reducing detrimental treatment side effects (
When paired with chemotherapy, hormone therapy, or another anticancer therapy, FMD can slow the growth of tumors in mice with tumors. It can also guard against induced toxicity in normal tissues (
In the DIRECT study, patients with FMD did not receive dexamethasone before doxorubicin-cyclophosphamide (AC) ChT. However, they did not have a higher rate of adverse events compared to patients in the control group. These statistics suggest that FMD may help prevent patients from experiencing various ChT-related complications such as nausea and vomiting, eliminating the need for dexamethasone premedication. Within certain therapeutic environments, the exclusion of dexamethasone administration could potentially enhance the anticancer effects of chemotherapy (
Two cycles of fasting/FMD improve antitumor immunity and facilitate the penetration of CD8+ T cells into tumors in preclinical in vivo trials by lowering blood IGF-1 levels, a crucial marker of the anticancer advantages of calorie restriction (
Both the development of mammospheres and their volume were decreased in the in vitro human TNBC SUM159 model when fasting and FMD-mimicking conditions were applied. These circumstances, which are also known as short-term starvation (STS), include low serum and low glucose levels. FMD cycles dramatically slowed the development of the tumor, decreased the size of the tumor, and elevated the expression of Caspase3 internal to the tumor, which is indicative of apoptotic activation (
Preclinical studies have demonstrated that STF could reduce the toxicity of various chemotherapeutic drugs and enhance their efficacy. A recent study found that STF can boost the impact of radiation based on preclinical investigations. In the clinical research field, FMD has demonstrated great potential in improving the efficacy and acceptance of chemotherapy. This can lead to unwanted side effects caused by chemotherapy and harm healthy cells by damaging their DNA (
Data on 24-hour dietary recall were collected from 2413 women with breast cancer who were between the ages of 27 and 70 and had no previous history of diabetes as part of general population research. Further investigation found that fasting for more than 13 hours per night was associated with a 36% decreased risk of breast cancer recurrence compared to fasting for less than 13 hours per night (hazard ratio, 1.36; 95% confidence interval, 1.05–1.76). This was the conclusion reached when the data were discussed in further detail (
Fasting-mimicking diets, or FMDs, were created to address the safety concerns associated with intermittent fasting. These problems include low rates of compliance and malnourishment. It was suggested that consuming fasting meals with low protein content, high healthy fats, and complex carbohydrates might be used as a short-term therapeutic program. It mimics the effects of fasting by decreasing activation of the insulin/glucose signaling pathway without leading to potential negative effects from essential nutritional deficiency (
During the fasting metabolic diet (FMD), patients were instructed to consume less than 400 kcal of vegetable juice daily, as well as certain quantities of light vegetable broth, beginning 36–48 hours before chemotherapy and continuing until 24 hours following treatment. Not only did FMD reduce fatigue, but it also avoided the decline in quality of life that was brought on by chemotherapy. This was accomplished without causing any major adverse effect (
In a study including 36 patients with hormone-receptor-positive/HER2 breast cancer, the combination of FMD with endocrine treatments has shown promising results. A total of ten cycles of FMD were administered to one patient during the course of the second-line therapy scenario, while two patients got eight cycles of the treatment (
Complete dietary restriction causes dramatic changes in the pro-growth signaling that is triggered by glucose and other foods in a number of different species. This results in metabolic reprogramming and an increased allocation of resources to defensive mechanisms (
It has been shown that these modifications may extend the lifetime of an individual and accelerate the regeneration of cells in a number of different systems, including the brain and hematological systems (
Prior research has shown that giving mice STS (short-term deprivation) after exposing them to lethal dosages of DXR decreases mortality. C57BL/6 mice were given various doses of DXR STS for 48 hours to investigate whether the preventive effects of STS include reducing DXR-induced heart damage. The treatment dosage and timing were determined to provide extended exposure to DXR across many cycles when matching clinical doses and regimens. Current data suggests that short calorie restriction (SCR) might be a helpful additional dietary approach. However, because of the inconsistent and insufficient evidence, treatment recommendations do not officially endorse SCR. Most studies on the safety and effectiveness of SCR in cancer patients have used a diverse group of individuals, making it difficult to analyze the precise effects of SCR (
Intermittent fasting (IF) uses dietary interventions that involve alternate periods of fasting and free feeding/eating. Using IF helps to maintain a calorie-restricted program that is relatively safe and can be maintained over a lifespan (
Furthermore, after an IF regimen, various tissues and organs become more resistant to a range of damaging stimuli, such as oxidative, proteotoxic stressors, traumatic, metabolic, and ionic (Longo et al. 2014).
Disease studies on animals have also revealed that IF has the potential to slow down the progression of several chronic diseases, including obesity, cancer, diabetes, neurodegenerative disorder, and vascular diseases (
Ketone levels, autophagy, and DNA repair are all increased during the first stages of intermittent fasting. There is an increase in stress resistance, antioxidant defenses, glucose production, intracellular protein synthesis, and mitochondrial biogenesis when it is present during periods of recovery such as eating and sleeping. The process of long-term adaptation improves blood glucose homeostasis and lipid metabolism, as well as lowers abdominal obesity and inflammation. It also increases the sensitivity of cells to insulin and the body’s resistance to insulin (Karbowska et al. 2012;
Considered one of the central regulatory regions, the hypothalamus responds immediately to peripheral impulses. IF influences the hypothalamus by increasing CRH and TRH levels, which regulate energy homeostasis, thereby reducing food intake and appetite during fasting (
Calorie restriction induced by IF inhibits the IGF-1/AKT and mTORC1 pathways in tumor cells, whereas activation of AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK), which is dependent on the nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide coenzyme deacetylase-1 (Sirtuin-1, SIRT1) and SIRT3 pathways, enables the inhibition of tumor cell proliferation. AMPK and SIRTs are reciprocally dependent on metabolic adaptation associated with IF (
SIRT1 has the ability to activate AMPK via liver kinase B1 (LKB1), while AMPK has the potential to activate SIRT1 through nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT as well). Additionally, FOXO3a, which is a protein that belongs to the downstream of SIRT1 and SIRT3, and AMPK are both capable of promoting the transcriptional activity of the other (
SIRT3 suppresses tumor growth by stimulating FOXO3a and enhancing SOD2 levels, leading to a reduction in reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels (
Recent research has shown that IF may alter tumor cell energy metabolism, reduce tumor cell proliferation, increase immune cell function, and boost anti-tumor immune responses, hinting that IF might be effective in tumor immunotherapy (
Although research on the impact of intermittent fasting (IF) in nonhuman primates is limited, clinical studies have been conducted to investigate its potential in controlling metabolic and hormonal factors related to cancer development or outcome. Trials have mostly included non-cancer patients, since different formulations of intermittent fasting have shown feasibility and a positive impact on weight reduction in overweight and obese individuals (
The ability to evade the immune system is essential to the development of cancer. IF has been shown to have an effect on the formation and functioning of a variety of immune cells, which in turn regulates antitumor immune responses and has an effect on the growth of cancer, according to research.
Interferon modulates antitumor immunity by enhancing the self-renewal ability of hematopoietic stem cells and enhancing immunosuppression. Moreover, the alteration in energy metabolism led to a significant reduction in IGF-1 and an increase in insulin-like growth factor-binding protein (
Moreover, elevated production of Heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) in malignancies has the potential to inhibit the demise of tumor cells and inhibit immune-stimulatory effects. (
IF has the potential to influence immune responses against cancer by modulating the activity of immune cells, including tumor-associated macrophages (TAMs) and natural killer (NK) cells (Englert et al. 2016). Intermittent fasting may enhance the body’s repair and immunological monitoring by stimulating AMPK and decrease the metabolic and inflammatory functions of monocytes via activation of the peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR), respectively. Blocked production of the chemokine C-C motif ligand 2 further reduces the number of monocytes associated with inflammation in the circulation and tissues during IF (
A number of yeast oncogene orthologues, including Ras and Sch9 (which is the functional orthologue of human S6K), have the ability to decrease the organism’s tolerance to stress in experimentation (
S. cerevisiae cells resistant to oxidative stress or chemotherapy showed a 100-fold increase in resistance to short-term fasting or deletion of proto-oncogene homologs (Sch9, both Sch9 and Ras2) compared to yeast cells containing the constitutively active oncogene homolog Ras2val19. Primary mouse glia cells were protected against damage caused by hydrogen peroxide or cyclophosphamide when cultured in a low-glucose medium. It did not provide equivalent protection for glioma and neuroblastoma cancer cell lines from mice, rats, or humans. Research results indicate that a two-day fast improved the survival rates of mice receiving high-dose etoposide and mice with neuroblastoma allografts compared to their non-fasted counterparts (
The antitumor effect of fasting is attributed to reductions in IGF1 and glucose levels, which may help distinguish the impact of anticancer therapy on benign cells from malignant ones. This technology will inhibit the growth of several types of cancerous cells, such as solid tumor cell lines, lymphoid cells, and murine leukemia cells. The main goal is to make cancer cells more responsive to tyrosine kinase inhibitors, chemotherapy, and radiation (
A diet that is low in carbs and high in fat is known as the ketogenic diet (KD), which is a calorie-controlled diet (
In the event of glucose deprivation, the body recognizes the necessity to generate an alternative form of energy for cellular functioning. Ketones and fatty acids produced by the liver are beneficial to healthy cells but not to malignant cells. The malfunctioning mitochondria and possible disruptions in the electron transport chain of cancer cells impede the regular synthesis of mitochondrial adenosine triphosphate (
Enzyme name | Description | Role in carcinogenesis | Effect of ketogenic diet on enzyme | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) | class of zinc-dependent endopeptidases that are important enzymes in the degradation of the extracellular matrix. | Numerous MMPs are involved in cancer development, migration, invasion, metastasis, and angiogenesis. | Significant decrease in MMP-9 expression in several kinds of cancer. |
|
Pyruvate kinase (PK) | terminal glycolytic enzyme that catalyzes ATP and pyruvate synthesis by converting phosphoenolpyruvate (PED) to adenosine diphosphate (ADP). | Pyruvate kinase M2 (PKM2) is the most abundant isoform involved in cancer cells and plays an important role in cancer metabolism. | KD inhibited the expression of PKM2, lowering glucose absorption and lactate formation in tumor cells, hence destroying the Warburg effect, which is thought to be a survival technique for cancer cells. |
|
P53 | Transcription factor in the nucleus that functions as a tumor suppressor factor. | It is involved in controlling cell proliferation, apoptosis, and genetic stability. | KD either prevents or silences p53 mutant function during malignant initiation and development. | Levine et al. 2009; |
AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) | serine/threonine protein kinase found in a variety of cells. | AMPK plays a critical role in cancer prevention. | Glucose replacement with ketone bodies in cancerous cells. |
|
The low-carbohydrate modified Atkins KD diet, which consists of < 20 grams of carbohydrates per day, was subjected to a feasibility trial for a duration of four weeks, conducted on PET-positive advanced cancer patients who had solid tumors. There was a correlation between insulin levels and ketosis, but not with IGF. A threefold rise in ketosis was seen in patients who were in a stable illness or partial remission, in comparison to patients who were experiencing progression of their condition. This occurred without any substantial changes in weight loss or calorie intake (
Twenty patients with recurrent glioblastoma who were receiving KD supplemented with plant oils were the subjects of the ERGO research, which was conducted by Rieger and colleagues (
A class of zinc-dependent endopeptidases, also referred to as matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), functions to contribute to the breakdown of extracellular matrix (ECM). This process is vital to establish and maintain cell integrity and, hence, the three-dimensional body structure (
The terminal glycolytic enzyme pyruvate kinase catalyzes the generation of ATP and pyruvate by changing phosphoenolpyruvate (PED) into adenosine diphosphate (ADP) (
A transcription factor P53, localized in the nucleus, is responsible for regulating cell proliferation, apoptosis, and genetic stability, which allows it to reduce the risk of tumor development (Levine et al. 2009). The protein ligase MDM2 is responsible for the destruction of P53, which is produced in normal cells at a very low activity level (Ozaki et al. 2011). On the other hand, mutations in p53 are common in the vast majority of cancers (
The serine/threonine protein kinase known as AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) may be found in different types of cells (
Furthermore, the ketogenic diet intake also promotes the glucose uptake in cancer cells by ketone bodies, which is reported to have an association with increased activation of AMPK (
Providing that there is no starvation, calorie restriction (CR) is the physiological strategy that has been shown to be the most effective and reliable in extending the lifespan of animals and avoiding cancer (
Reduced anabolic hormone and growth factor production (Merry et al. 1981;
Diminished generation of reactive oxygen species, lower oxidative stress, and free radicals that caused damage to DNA (
Lowered plasma inflammatory cytokine levels and a rise in circulating ghrelin, corticosteroids, and adiponectin, resulting in inflammatory reduction (
Simultaneously, CR influences several pathways involved in cancer formation. These activities include accelerated DNA repair mechanisms, enhanced removal of damaged cells by apoptosis, better autophagy, and protection against many harmful agents such as genotoxic and toxic chemicals (
The benefits of CR include several different impacts, including the stimulation of genes that inhibit cancers, the support of DNA and cell repair, the regulation of protein turnover, the enhancement of stress tolerance, and the promotion of antioxidant activity. Additionally, it inhibits the activity of genes that are responsible for inflammation and has an impact on gene modulation, mostly via the regulation of gene expression. Calorie restriction strategies and methods (
IGF-1, in conjunction with other anabolic hormones such as insulin and sex steroids, regulates the metabolism of energy, the development and specialization of cells, the size of the body, and the longevity of an individual dependent on the amount of calories and protein that they consume (
Dwarf mice lacking growth hormone (GH) and insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) experience weight increase in middle age and have a lifespan that is about 40% longer (
Excess adiposity due to excessive calorie consumption and insufficient physical exercise increases the chance of getting cancer, according to data from experimental and epidemiological research. Calorie restriction without starvation and potentially protein restriction, on the other hand, prevent cancer.
Over the course of the last three decades, several studies have been carried out associating fasting with cancer treatment. The role of fasting as intermittent fasting, short-term fast mimicking diet, and other calorie deprivation methods showed a great impact on cancer on the molecular level and even showed significant potency as a therapeutic agent along with chemotherapy.
The anti-Warburg action caused tumor cells to undergo apoptosis and oxidative stress while also promoting cell proliferation.
Fasting may influence the capacity of the modified cancer cell to develop and invade while also reducing the frequency of oncogene mutations. Calorie restriction, the ketogenic diet, and intermittent fasting were dietary changes that demonstrated a significant impact on cancer prevention and also had a great deal of potential as therapeutic agents. The implemented dietary modifications led to several beneficial outcomes, including a reduction in the activation of pro-aging pathways, inflammation, and growth in precancerous and normal adjacent cells, and an increase in apoptosis in damaged cells. Even though pinpointing every environmental and genetic element would provide us with a complete road map for the future in terms of lowering the incidence of cancer and improving treatment, there are still a lot of unresolved problems with this illness.
The authors are grateful to the applied science private university, Amman, Jordan, for the full support granted to this review (grant number DRGS-2024-1).