Research Article |
Corresponding author: Ala Abu-Zaid ( a.abuzaid@bau.edu.jo ) Academic editor: Evgeni Grigorov
© 2024 Ala Abu-Zaid, Sawsan Abu-Zaid, Muna Barakat, Rashed Al-Huniti, Hamzeh Khair.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Abu-Zaid A, Abu-Zaid S, Barakat M, Al-Huniti R, Khair H (2024) Effectiveness of combination therapy of magnesium, vitamin B2 and Co-enzyme 10 supplementation on vestibular migraine: a retrospective cohort study. Pharmacia 71: 1-7. https://doi.org/10.3897/pharmacia.71.e112909
|
Vestibular migraine (VM) has conventionally been treated through acute migraine-aborting therapeutic interventions and prevention to reduce migraines’ occurrence, length and intensity. There is growing attention to the development of non-pharmaceutical prophylactic interventions for migraines in the search for effective treatments, such as through mineral, vitamin and other supplementation. This research aims to examine the effectiveness of magnesium, vitamin B2 and Co-enzyme 10 supplementation to decrease vestibular migraines’ frequency, duration and severity. Method: This retrospective cohort study was conducted in a Jordanian context over 57- VM patients, each patient attending the outpatient dizziness clinic between August 2022 and February 2023. Patients were treated for six months with a combined supplementation of magnesium, vitamin B2, and Co-enzyme Q10. Assessments were made of three measures of VM attack, namely frequency, duration and severity, both before and after intervention. Result: Supplements administration demonstrated a significant reduction (by 81.1%) in VM-symptoms frequency (p < 0.001). Moreover, reductions in symptom duration in minutes occurred progressively as the treatment period continued and showed statistical significance, with impacts upon over 80% of the sample and a reduction from 763.9 minutes to 122.5 minutes (p < 0.001). The mean of pre-intervention severity was 7.2/10, with a significant decrease shown following treatment, at 2.1/10, and very positive results for over 71% of the sample (p < 0.001). Conclusion: The preliminary findings of this study showed a promising potential for such supplements in the treatment and prevention of VM; however, more research and a prospective trial are recommended.
Vestibular Migraine (VM), Vitamin B 2 (Riboflavin), Magnesium, Co-enzyme Q10
Vestibular migraine (VM) is the most frequent and second most frequent causal factor, respectively, in spontaneous episodic vertigo and vertigo (
VM diagnoses are made based on clinical patient histories. The condition presents diagnostic challenge based on the absence of agreed biomarkers or diagnostic testing to confirm the diagnosis (
Vestibular Migraine | Probable Vestibular Migraine |
---|---|
A. Minimum of five episodes including moderate or severe vestibular symptoms, of duration between five minutes and 72 hours. | A. Minimum of five episodes including moderate or severe vestibular symptoms, of duration between five minutes and 72 hours. |
B. Currently or previously experiencing migraine, which may or may not have an aura, following the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD) | B. A single criterion from VM criteria B and C is met: either history of migraines or migraine characteristics in the episodes, but not both. |
C. Single or multiple migrainous symptoms alongside a minimum of half of vestibular episodes: | C. Symptoms cannot be more satisfactorily explained by other vestibular/ICHD diagnoses. |
• Headache accompanied by 2 or more of the symptoms listed: located on a single side of the head, feeling of pulsation, pain is from moderate to high severity, exacerbated when carrying out normal physical activities | |
• Phono- and photo-phobia | |
• Aura (experienced visually) | |
D. Symptoms cannot be more satisfactorily explained by other vestibular/ICHD diagnoses. |
Pathophysiological processes in VM remain poorly understood. However, these probably have similarities to classical migraines. In both diagnoses, females are significantly more highly represented, lacking a detailed explanation (
VM management can include lifestyle changes, exercises to improve spatial orientation perception, modified diet, medication, and vestibular physical therapy (
Guidance issued by the European Federation of Neurological Societies suggests that prophylaxis may be appropriate if the patient has a significantly limited quality of life, if they suffer more than one acute migraine per month, if migraines are unresponsive to acute interventions, or where auras are frequently-occurring, lengthy or cause discomfort (
In spite of this wide range of interventions, patient dissatisfaction remains high, as conventional medications are costly and ideal control is frequently not attained. Moreover, the large, randomized placebo-based control trials required to verify the effectiveness of the interventions have not been carried out (
Thus, the growing attention to developing alternative options to pharmaceuticals in prophylactic treatment of migraine is partially underpinned by the requirements for efficacy with a lower adverse effects burden, and this has led to assessments of vitamin and mineral supplements, as well as herbal medicines (
The current article reports on a study applying six-month supplementation with Vitamin B2, Co-enzyme 10, and magnesium as a prophylactic for preventing acute VM. Here, efficacy is examined for this regimen in reductions in the rate of occurrence, length and intensity of attacks.
The research was developed following a retrospective analytical observational design and carried out in Jordan at Royal Medical Services Hospital, at the outpatient dizziness clinic within the Department of Otolaryngology. The clinic is at a tertiary facility and patients are referred from secondary and primary care contexts.
This retrospective cohort study had a patient sample of 57 individuals enrolling in the period August 2022 to February 2023. Each patient was examined for neurological, ear, nose and throat issues, and then an audio vestibular investigations done were, PTA (Pure Tone Audiometry), VNG (Video Nystagmo Gram), c+o-VEMP (cervical and ocular Vestibular Myogenic Evoked Potentials), the imaging method was Brain MRI. The sample was selected in line with specific criteria and patients were included in the study group if they met all these criteria (Table
Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
---|---|
Patients were included in the study group if they met all these criteria | |
Males and females attending the outpatient clinic | Any VM patient with further neurological or vestibular diagnoses were excluded |
Aged between 17–85 years | Any VM patient who taking further medications to treat migraines; B-blockers, Ca-Channel blockers, Tricyclic Antidepressants, anti-epileptic drugs |
Had a primary VM diagnosis* | Any VM patient who discontinued treatment before the planned duration had finished |
Women who were pregnant or breastfeeding |
Data was gathered concerning VM in terms of length, severity and rate of occurrence, with each of these factors being measured prior and post-supplementation.
Patients were given six months’ combined supplements consisting of 200 mg Vitamin B 2 tablet (once daily), 300 mg Magnesium tablet (once daily) and 100 mg Co-enzyme 10 tablets (three times daily). For the study patients, no other medicines were prescribed to treat VM.
Criteria used to evaluate effectiveness included: frequency of VM, expressed as days with attacks each month; severity, the scaling of dizziness severity used is NDS (Numeric Dizziness scale), from (0–10); which is a subjective individual rating scale designed to quantify dizziness intensity; in which 0 refers to no dizziness and 10 to the worst imaginable dizziness (
The collected data was analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS), 24th Edition, applying mean, standard deviation (SD) and percentage frequency to analyze category and continuous variables. Between-group variations in VM length, intensity and frequency were evaluated pre- and post-intervention, using paired-t tests. Findings with p-values of 0.05 and below were assessed as statistically significant.
This research followed the ethical standards set out by Royal Medical Services in their Medical Committee’s declaration.
Overall, 57 patients took part in the research undergoing assessments prior to and following dietary supplementation with Vitamin B 2 (1 × 200 mg daily), Co-enzyme 10 (3 × 100 mg daily) and magnesium (1 × 300 mg daily). The sample had a mean age of 43.5±16.8, and 75% of individuals (n = 43) were females (see Table
Variables | ||
• Age (mean ± STD) | 43.5±16.8 | |
Gender | N | % |
• Females | 43 | 75.4 |
• Males | 14 | 24.6 |
Before supplementation, the average length of an attack was 763.9 minutes, while the mean occurrence was 13.0 times per month. A significant reduction of over 80% was identified following the provision of the supplements, as shown in Table
The duration, frequency and severity of VM symptoms were assessed pre- and post-supplementation (n = 57).
Measured variables | Pre | Post | Mean reduction (%) | T | p-value * | ||
Mean | STD | Mean | STD | ||||
Symptom duration (in minutes) | 763.9 | 131.40 | 122.5 | 57.87 | 641.4(81.7) | 4.0 | <0.001 |
Symptom severity (scored 0–10) | 7.2 | 1.7 | 2.1 | 2.2 | 5.1(71.9) | 17.2 | <0.001 |
Frequency (per month) | 13.0 | 12.5 | 2.9 | 5.9 | 10.1(81.1) | 6.9 | <0.001 |
The mean reduction in duration, frequency and severity of VM symptoms were assessed after supplementation per Gender (n = 57).
Measured variables | Female | Male | p-value * | ||
Mean Reduction | STD | Mean Reduction | STD | ||
• Duration of symptoms (min) | 722.9 | 130.3 | 390.9 | 79.9 | 0.044 |
• Frequency (per month) | 11.1 | 11.9 | 7.1 | 7.9 | 0.055 |
• Severity of symptoms (Scale 0–10) | 5.4 | 1.9 | 4.3 | 2.8 | 0.116 |
The results shown in Figs
VM is the most frequent causal factor in recurring spontaneous vertigo, affecting approximately 1% of people and 10% of those suffering migraines. Moreover, females are disproportionately affected by VM, at a ratio of 3:1 compared to males (
Clinically, the underuse of drugs to prevent migraines has been identified, and preventive treatment approaches and principles are a significant factor in enhancing compliance, reducing adverse effects, and optimizing patient outcomes (
According to
The findings of this retrospective cohort study illustrate that the sample improved significantly across the measures used, which were duration, rate of occurrence and severity when evaluated following six months’ treatment with magnesium, vitamin B2, and co-enzyme Q10 supplements. Frequency (number of days/month) with vestibular migraine decreased from 13.0 to 2.9, statistically significant, with a p-value of p <0.001. Moreover, over 80% of the sample stated that they experienced significant decreases in VM attack length (p < 0.001). Severity in vestibular migraine as assessed through the vertigo analogue showed a mean value of 7.2/10 prior to treating with supplements, and 2.1/10 following six months’ treatment, which represents a significant decrease, with good results found for over 71% of the sample (p < 0.001). Although, there was a significant difference between female and male in terms of duration of symptoms; hence, the mean reduction in female was 722.2 min, while for male 390.0 min. There was not a significant difference between them in terms of frequency and severity of symptoms
Although a range of previous nutraceutical research and reviews has been conducted to assess supplementation and its effect on migraine symptom reduction (
The final major finding in this study is that the participants did not report any severe adverse events during the supplementation period. The adverse events reported in the study were mild, limited to two reports of urine discoloring orange and a single report of mild diarrhea. However, two participants withdrew and were then excluded from the study, as they stopped taking the treatment before the end of the period because of adverse events, with one reporting anxiety while the other stated that their headaches had increased. These two events are not linked to the use of the supplements provided (
Our current study found that supplementing with these constituents offered good tolerance and efficacy as a complementary therapy for preventing vestibular migraine. On the other hand, the study had a small sample and used a limited duration of follow-up, with the comparatively high cost of this approach against different prophylaxis. This restricted the participant numbers and significantly limited the study.
AA was the study’s principal investigator and SA the project manager. MB undertook data analysis, and RA and HK were responsible for data collection. AA contributed to writing this article, with all authors reading and approving the finished manuscript.
All data and materials are available on request.
The study reported here supports the potential effectiveness of proprietary dietary supplementation with Vitamin B2, Co-enzyme 10 and Magnesium, as well as the low level and mostly non-severe nature of adverse reactions to this treatment. The findings point to the need for continued research and a prospective trial.